Explanation evaluation (t3)

A survey to evaluate summarized and relavent explanations.

100%

Scenario 1

Query: Artists born in the US and died in France

Result: Nina Simone is an artist born in the US died in France

Please rate how effective the following statements are to justify the result above.

Rating guideline: A score of 1 means "least effective", a score of 5 means "most effective", and the scores of 2, 3, and 4 are "somewhere in between".

	1	2	3	4	5
Nina Simone is an artist. Sources: Nina Simone: DBpedia is a: RDF vocabulary Artist: Dbpedia schema
Nina Simone is a musical artist. Sources: Nina Simone: DBpedia is a: RDF vocabulary Musical Artist: Dbpedia schema
Musical artists are artists. Sources: Musical artists: Dbpedia schema are: RDF vocabulary artists: Dbpedia schema
Nina Simone was born in the United States. Sources: Nina Simone: DBpedia was born in: Dbpedia schema United States: DBpedia
Nina Simone was born in Collettsville. Sources: Nina Simone: DBpedia was born in: Dbpedia schema Collettsville: DBpedia
Collettsville is located in the United States. Sources: Collettsville: DBpedia is located in: GeoNames schema United States: DBpedia
Collettsville (DBpedia) is same as Collettsville (GeoNames). Sources: Collettsville: DBpedia is same as: OWL Web Ontology Language Collettsville: GeoNames
Collettsville is located in the United States. Sources: Collettsville: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema United States: DBpedia
Collettsville is located in North Carolina. Sources: Collettsville: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema North Carolina: GeoNames
North Carolina is located in the United States. Sources: North Carolina: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema United States: DBpedia
North Carolina is located in the United States. Sources: North Carolina: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema United States: GeoNames
United States (GeoNames) is same as United States (DBpedia). Sources: United States: GeoNames is same as: OWL Web Ontology Language United States: DBpedia
Nina Simone died in France. Sources: Nina Simone: DBpedia died in: Dbpedia schema France: DBpedia
Nina Simone died in Carry-le-Rouet. Sources: Nina Simone: DBpedia died in: Dbpedia schema Carry-le-Rouet: DBpedia
Carry-le-Rouet is located in France. Sources: Collettsville: DBpedia is located in: GeoNames schema France: DBpedia
Carry-le-Rouet (DBpedia) is same as Carry-le-Rouet (GeoNames). Sources: Carry-le-Rouet: DBpedia is same as: OWL Web Ontology Language Carry-le-Rouet: GeoNames
Carry-le-Rouet is located in France. Sources: Carry-le-Rouet: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema France: DBpedia
Carry-le-Rouet is located in Arrondissement d'Istres. Sources: Carry-le-Rouet: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema Arrondissement d'Istres: GeoNames
Arrondissement d'Istres is located in France. Sources: Arrondissement d'Istres: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema France: DBpedia
Arrondissement d'Istres is located in Département des Bouches-du-Rhône. Sources: Arrondissement d'Istres: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema Département des Bouches-du-Rhône: GeoNames
Département des Bouches-du-Rhône is located in France. Sources: Département des Bouches-du-Rhône: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema France: DBpedia
Département des Bouches-du-Rhône is located in Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur. Sources: Département des Bouches-du-Rhône: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur: GeoNames
Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur is located in France. Sources: Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema France: DBpedia
Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur is located in France. Sources: Région Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur: GeoNames is located in: GeoNames schema France: GeoNames
France (DBpedia) is same as France (GeoNames). Sources: France: DBpedia is same as: OWL Web Ontology Language France: GeoNames

Hint: to rate a statement, you can think of it as if it's a good statement or a bad statement to explain the query result. If it's a good statement, assign a higher score, if it's a bad statement assign a lower score.